SSCP — Controversies, Consequences and the collapse by B.R. Haran

https://kalyan98.wordpress.com/2008/02/06/rama-setu-in-the-midst-of-political-prejudices/Thursday February 7 2008 00:00 ISTúNÕ §hPjûR ¨û\úYt\j RVe¡]ôp Uôod£V Lmë.ÜPu CûQkÕ úTôWôhPm: Ck§V Lmë. ùNVXo Rô.Tôi¥Vu úTh¥£YLeûL, ©l. 6: úNÕ NØj§Wj §hPjûR Uj§V AWÑ ¨û\úYt\j RVe¡]ôp CûR ùNVpTÓjR Y#Ùßj§ Uôod£V Lmë. Lh£ÙPu CûQkÕ Ck§V Lmë²vh úTôWôhPm SPjÕm G] Ck§V Lmë²vh Uô¨Xf ùNVXo Rô.Tôi¥Vu ùR¬®jRôo. £YLeûL«p ×Ru¡ZûU ¨ÚToLÞdÏ AYo A°jR úTh¥: Lôe¡Wv Lh£ûVf úNokR §d®_n£e úNÕ NØj§Wj §hPm ϱjÕ ×§V ×W° ¡[l©Ùs[ôo. AYo úNÕ §hPm ϱjÕ BnÜ ùNnV Cuàm 6 BiÓ BÏm G]d á±Ùs[ôo. Uj§V AWÑdÏ BRWÜ ùLôÓjÕYÚm Lh£Ls úNokÕ HtßdùLôiP §hPjûR §d®_n£e Ïû\ á±VÕ N¬VpX. úNÕ §hPjûR Uj§V AWÑ ¨û\úYt\ô®hPôp CûR HtßdùLôs[dá¥V Lh£LÞPu áhP¦ ûYlúTôm. EfN ¿§Uu\m úNÕ NØj§Wj §hPjÕdÏ ØÝûUVôLj RûP ®§dL®pûX. WôUo TôXm G]d á\lTÓm NofûNdϬV Tϧ«p UhÓm §hPl T¦Ls SûPùT\j RûP ®§jÕs[Õ. Ck§V LPúXôWd LôYpTûP R[T§ úNÕ NØj§Wj §hPm ϱjÕ LÚjÕ ùR¬®j§ÚlTÕ Uj§V AWÑ GkR®R A§LôWØm CpXôUp ùNVpTÓYûRd LôhÓ¡\Õ. CkRj §hPjûR ¨û\úYtßYÕ Ï±jÕ Uj§V AWÑm RªZL Lôe¡Wv RûXYoLÞm ReL[Õ ¨ûXûVj ùR°YôL UdLÞdÏ ®[dL úYiÓm. WôUo ùTVWôp úNÕ §hPjÕdÏ ÕúWôLm CûZdLlTÓYûR Ck§V Lmë²vh Lh£ ùTôßjÕdùLôs[ôÕ. úNÕ NØj§Wj §hPjûR Uj§V AWÑ ¨û\úYt\j RY±]ôp CûR ¨û\úYt\ Y#Ùßj§ Uôod£V Lmë²vh Lh£ÙPu CûQkÕ Ck§V Lmë²vh úTôWôhPeLs SPjRj §hPªPlThÓs[Õ. ØmûT«p Bh£ ùNnÙm Lôe¡Wv AWÑm Uj§«p Bh£ ùNnÙm Lôe¡Wv AWÑm LXYWd ÏmTpLû[ AàU§jÕ YÚ¡\Õ. CkRd ÏmTpLû[ Uj§V AWÑ LÓm SPY¥dûL GÓjÕ JÓdL Lmë²vh Lh£ Y#ÙßjÕ¡\Õ Gu\ôo.http://www.dinamani.com/NewsItems.asp?ID=DNT20080206110057&Title=TamilNadu+Page&lTitle=R%AAZLm&Topic=0&dName=No+Title&Dist= Thursday February 7 2008 00:00 ISTúNÕ §hPjûR RûP ùNnV UR EQoÜLû[ çiP N§: EVo Lp®j Õû\ AûUfNo L. ùTôuØ¥ùNuû], ©l. 6: úNÕ §hPjûRj RûPlTÓjÕm YûL«p UR EQoÜLû[j çiP ØVt£ SPd¡\Õ Guß EVo Lp®j Õû\ AûUfNo L. ùTôuØ¥ ùR¬®jRôo. ©oXô úLô[WeLm-A±®Vp SLWj§p ùNuû] A±®Vp ®Zô-2008 Utßm A±®Vp LiLôh£ûV ×Ru¡ZûU ùRôPe¡ ûYjÕ AûUfNo úT£VRôYÕ: A±®Vp çVô] AÔÏØû\Lû[ C[m Es[eL°p EÚYôdL úYiÓm. úNÕ NØj§Wj §hPjÕdÏ “WôUo TôXm’ ©Wf£û] êXm AW£Vp çVôLÜm, UR EQoÜLû[j çi¥Ùm RûP ùNnV ØVt£ SPd¡\Õ. A±®Vp Y[of£dÏ CÕúTôu\ LÚjÕLs RûPVôL Es[ûR Cû[OoLs ׬kÕ ùLôs[ úYiÓm. AlúTôÕRôu YÚeLôX NØRôVm Y[of£ ùTßm…http://www.dinamani.com/NewsItems.asp?ID=DNT20080206130029&Title=TamilNadu+Page&lTitle=R%AAZLm&Topic=0&dName=No+Title&Dist=0

http://www.haindavakeralam.com/HkPage.aspx?PAGEID=5456&SKIN=B                                                                                               
SSCP — Controversies, Consequences and the collapse by B.R. Haran

When the Sethu Samudram Channel Project (SSCP) was proposed, every one involved knew that it was not viable. Both the central and state governments knew that they have not done proper studies on the impact of environmental and security factors on the project and despite that they inaugurated it.

Prime Minister being an expert in economics must also have been aware of the economical non-viability of the project. When the Rama Sethu movement was at the initial stages, both the governments knew that the issue would magnify into alarming proportions and despite that they continued the dredging.

When the cases were filed in the Courts of Law, both the governments knew that the dredging at the site of Rama Sethu would be ”’stayed’ and even then they continued the dredging. The controversial ASI affidavit was submitted deliberately knowing the volatile nature of the issue. Even after withdrawing the affidavit, the Centre allowed DMK to constitute a subservient committee of eminent persons knowing pretty well what sort of recommendations would be submitted by such a committee.

The DMK also knew that the centre would dump the project at one point of time and both the governments knew very well that they cannot win the case at the Courts of Law. But, still dredging is continued. The shipping minister had recently conveyed that baring the location of Rama Sethu, 80% of dredging has been completed and once the stay is lifted by the SC, the balance 20% would be completed. But, RTI applications filed by former government officials and citizen committees such as ‘Coastal Action Network’ have not been answered until now.

Recently, when the Naval Chief Admiral Suresh Mehta was in Chennai, he has opined with a lot of ‘Naval Sense’ that the SSCP doesn’t make any nautical sense, particularly regarding the navigation of bigger vessels through the canal and when the media men asked him to elaborate on the issue, he wisely refused by saying, “This is Tamil Nadu and it is a sensitive issue”.

He must have definitely had the Dravidian Leaders in his mind when he made that statement and T.R.Balu’s letter to the Defence Minister asking for a clarification statement from the Naval Chief, proved it right. It is human tendency to get agitated and react in a rude manner when literally cornered and a certain defeat is staring at one’s face.

The Union Shipping Minister T.R.Balu is exactly in that kind of a situation now, especially when the Central Government has allegedly decided to put the project in cold storage, which might eventually lead to the scrapping of this worthless project proposed by the DPA leaders to hoodwink the people of Tamil Nadu in the name of progress and prosperity.

When the entire cabinet has stood against the Shipping Minister in a recently held meeting on SSCP, how can he expect A.K.Antony to impress upon the Naval Chief to issue a statement of clarification, especially when the Defence Minister is also aware of the navigational limitations and implications of the project?

Nevertheless, the Defence Minister’s reaction (reply) has come now, in the form of statement from Director General of Coast Guard. Vice Admiral R.F. Contractor, the DG of Coast Guard, has stated that the SSCP poses a grave threat to National Security and that the movements of militants and terrorists would increase after the commencement of ship movements through the canal.

He has also opined that organizations like LTTE would make use of it posing danger to civilian ships as well.  The people are also aware of the fact that the Naval Chief and the Coast Guard Chief are more qualified than Balu and his committee of “eminences” – the committee didn’t have a marine expert – in matters concerning SSCP.

In this context, the AIADMK supremo Jayalalitha has scored a political point over her archrival Chief Minister Karunanidhi by demanding the sacking of the Shipping Minister T.R.Balu for sending an uncouth letter to the Defence Minister. Also, Rama Sethu Protection Movement’s activists have paid back the DMK with the same coins by asking, “Is Balu an engineer? In which engineering college he studied?”

According to Janatha Partry President Dr. Subramaniam Swamy Rs.800 crores that have been spent so far have been done at the behest of the Union Shipping and Transport Minister T.R.Baalu without security clearance from the armed forces and intelligence agencies as well as without obtaining prior clearance of the Tamil Nadu Pollution Control Board, and hence the amount should be recovered by prosecuting T.R.Baalu and by attaching his assets and his benami companies.

The Supreme Court now has placed the centre in a catch 22 situation of filing two affidavits, one on the alignment and the other on the studies undertaken so far to ascertain the antiquity (ancientness) of the monument (Rama Sethu). On one side the DMK is standing on the centre’s head to destruct Rama Sethu and on the other side the centre has to break its head on the ‘studies’, which it has not undertaken so far!   

At this juncture, the best thing to do for the government is to scrap the project on the grounds of economy, environment and security and save its face. The most important point to note in this long and sordid episode is that those who are voicing for the implementation of SSCP are the very same persons who are supporting LTTE!”

Both LTTE-support and the SSCP-campaign are made in the name of “Tamil” and those who oppose both LTTE and SSCP on “National Interests” are branded as “Anti Tamils”! If the opponents are branded as “anti-Tamils” , what is wrong in branding the supporters as “anti-Nationals”?

The problem with this mediocre bunch of “Dravidians” is that, they fail to understand that the majority of Tamil people are having National Interests on top priority. In the meantime the Tamil Nadu Government has said that the SSCP is a “prestige” issue! One is compelled to ask, “Which is important, DMK/DK’s prestige or Nation’s security?” In this ongoing war on SSCP, who will win, the so-called “anti-Tamils” or the well-exposed “anti-Nationals”? The result is written on the wall!

The activists of the Rama Sethu Protection Movement are of the opinion that Ram Lila” has just begun and the scrapping of the project is imminent, and what follows along with the arrival of the new government (BJP led NDA) at the centre, will be a series of actions on SSCP and its collapse. They feel that it is not only defeat, which is staring at the face of the UPA, but also these series of actions and many inconvenient questions. Will the next government act accordingly? We have to wait and see! 

http://www.haindavakeralam.com/HkPage.aspx?PAGEID=5456&SKIN=B

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: